Hi, I’m Freeman!
Have you ever wondered what really separates a beginner from an intermediate classical guitarist?
Unlike language tests like TOEIC or English proficiency exams, guitar doesn’t come with clear-cut levels.
Sure, there are grade certifications like those offered by the Japan Guitar Federation, but today we’re not talking about official exams.
Let’s explore the practical differences between beginner and intermediate players, so you can understand where you stand and how to level up.
I used to think a lot about what rank I was at. Of course, one could just perform in front of others, and they’d decide for themselves:
“Ah, this person is still a beginner.”
“Hmm, definitely an advanced player.”
Everyone’s judgment is different, but we can’t help being curious about our own level.
That’s why I want to share my thoughts on the differences between beginners and intermediate players based on my long experience.
Advanced players?
That’s for another time! For now, let’s focus on moving from beginner to intermediate—the first milestone most players aim for.
Defining Beginners vs. Intermediate Players
Let’s start by clarifying what I mean:
| Beginner | Intermediate |
|---|---|
| Just started guitar | Can play a fair amount of pieces |
| Mainly practicing exercises from method books | Can perform pieces that look good in recitals |
| Doesn’t fully understand the importance of nails | Understands the importance of nails |
| I think I’m an intermediate | I think I’m a beginner |
Of course, these definitions can be debated endlessly. For our purposes, we’ll focus on what is generally perceived.
Playing Recuerdos de la Alhambra: The Tremolo Test
One of the clearest benchmarks is Francisco Tárrega’s Recuerdos de la Alhambra.
Why? The tremolo technique in this piece requires steady thumb-bass coordination while your fingers create a flowing melody. For beginners, this is a serious challenge.
Being able to play this piece—memorized or with the sheet music—is a great indicator that you’re moving past the beginner stage. You don’t need to imitate famous performers perfectly; just completing it shows progress.
Memorization Tip: Playing the piece without looking at the sheet music is a key milestone for intermediate players.
Here’s a reference performance:
Nail Care and Finger Awareness: A Must for Intermediate Players
In classical guitar, nails are more than cosmetic—they’re part of your instrument. Like a bow for a violin, nails shape your tone and articulation.
Even if you play fingertip style, which produces a warm, soft sound, understanding the impact of nails on your tone is essential for progressing to intermediate level.
What to focus on:
- Nail shape and filing techniques
- Nail strength and flexibility
- Tone control with different nail conditions
Mastering these aspects can take years, but it’s a defining trait of intermediate players.
Once you start experimenting and adjusting, your sound and playing style will improve significantly.
Objective Self-Assessment: Knowing Your Strengths and Weaknesses
Beginners often overestimate their skill, while intermediate players start noticing gaps in their technique.
At this stage, you’ll:
- Listen to other players carefully
- Ask, “How do I play this like them?”
- Focus on phrases or pieces you aspire to master
When you can objectively assess your own abilities and practice deliberately, you’ve likely reached the intermediate level—or even beyond.
This mindset separates casual players from those who are truly advancing.
Summary: How to Recognize the Leap from Beginner to Intermediate
- Beginner: Following method books, experimenting with basic pieces, little awareness of nails
- Intermediate: Can perform more expressive pieces, aware of nail technique, objectively evaluates skill
Being able to play Recuerdos de la Alhambra, taking care of your nails, and objectively understanding your abilities are three key signs that you’re on the path from beginner to intermediate.
Keep practicing, stay curious, and enjoy the journey!
Don’t forget to check out my guitar channel for tips, performances, and inspiration:
